July 27, 2023

expert reaction to preprint on a superconductor showing levitation at room temperature and atmospheric pressure

A preprint was posted that claimed to have made a superconductor showing levitation at room temperature and atmospheric pressure.

Prof Susannah Speller, Professor of Materials Science at the University of Oxford, and Professor Chris Grovenor, Professor of Materials at the University of Oxford, said:

“The recent preprint by Lee, Kim and Kwon suggesting that they have observed room temperature superconductivity in the copper doped lead phosphate system, without the need for very high applied pressures, is interesting, but not yet wholly convincing.  The data presented showing a sharp drop in bulk resistivity suggests an abrupt phase transition around 100 oC, but whether this is a result of the formation of a superconducting state is not clear.  A similarly sharp transition in the magnetisation signal would be expected at the same temperature if a significant volume of the sample has become superconducting, as well as an anomaly in the specific heat capacity.  Neither of these features is evident in the data presented, and so it is too early to say that we have been presented with compelling evidence for superconductivity in these samples.  It will be interesting to see if other laboratories can repeat and improve on these preliminary observations.”

Dr Amalia Coldea, Associate Professor of Quantum Materials, University of Oxford, said:

“Witnessing discoveries in a newly synthesized quantum material is very exciting as nature reveals new phenomena that need to be understood. The initial observations always require diligent verification and reproducibility following the scientific method. We live in an era in which, more than ever, reliable and trusted research are pivotal to the progress in science.

“A recent manuscript on the potential room temperature superconductivity was reported on the archive (arXiv:2307.12037) and it was also published on 30 April 2023 DOI: (10.6111/JKCGCT.2023.33.2.061).

“While the presented results are potentially exciting, the presentation and the analysis of the results should be improved and all measurements need to be verified. Only when the experimental results are verified by many groups around the world we would be ready to embrace the long-sought room temperature superconductivity.”

Prof Toby Perring, Senior Scientist at the STFC Isis Neutron and Muon Source, said:

“If corroborated this would certainly be a very exciting discovery: room temperature superconductivity well above room temperature at ambient pressure has never been observed before. Of course, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and it is important that the time-honoured process of independent peer review of the authors’ submissions to the preprint server is followed. For the discovery to be accepted other research groups must be able to synthesise the material and reproduce room temperature superconductivity, while eliminating other physical phenomena that might have resulted in similar experimental signatures.”

Dr Mohammad Yazdani-Asrami of the University of Glasgow’s James Watt School of Engineering said:

“A real, working room-temperature superconductor which works at ambient pressure would be one of the holy grails of modern physics, unlocking major new developments in energy, transportation, healthcare, and communications.

“As it stands, however, the paper is not yet peer-reviewed and has not yet been tested in other labs to see if other researchers can reproduce its results. These are both key to determining for sure whether the world should be getting excited about the authors’ claims, which need much more scrutiny at this early stage. If the claims of findings are approved, perhaps, this is one of the most significant achievements of last few decades in physics and material engineering.

“Even before those standards are applied, the published results show that the critical current, in-field performance, and mechanical properties of the new material need improvement, to make it useful for energy and transport sector applications, in devices such as cable, motors, and transformers, and magnets in fusion industry. However, achieving this superconducting phase at ambient pressure is already a significant achievement which should be valued.

“Even though this work lit a glimmer of hope for all of us within the superconductivity community and beyond, much more work needs to be done to verify and explore the results. I will watch the developments with keen interest.”

Stuart Bradley, Principal Engineer (Power Electronics and Electrical Machines), WMG at The University of Warwick, said:

“There are some further considerations for the research. For example, it is not clear how electrical frequency affects the resistance.

“There are lots of impacts of the research. Superconductivity at room temperature and pressure would mean that the electricity transmission system could be smaller and possibly cheaper – and conduction losses would be zero, therefore improving efficiency. The national grid loses energy in the long, high-voltage lines. This would allow further electrification within the UK, but also a much larger interconnection between nations – such as Morocco to UK or Iceland to UK to import zero carbon renewable energy.

“The advances in the field could also help electrical machines become more efficient and smaller; electrical machines such as wind turbine generators could be much smaller and would be limited by mechanical design rather than electromagnetics. Moreover, the design flexibility of having much smaller machines might help their applications such as aerospace or robotics. Electrical devices such as sensors (like medical scanners) could also be smaller, less intrusive and cheaper.

“The implications don’t stop there. Magnetic fields for industrial processes could be more commercially viable – such as induction heating for iron and steel making. Energy storage and grid support (for voltage and frequency variation) is cheaper and can be distributed, meaning that more renewables can be connected to the grid. Computing might be made with little loss, or at higher speeds. Quantum computing might take advantage of the zero loss too – and perhaps data storage might be faster too.”

‘Superconductor Pb10−xCux(PO4)6O showing levitation at room temperature and atmospheric pressure and mechanism’ by Sukbae Lee et al. was uploaded to the preprint server arxiv on 22^nd July 2023. It has not been through peer review.

https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12037

Declared interests

No reply to our request for DOIs was received.